Introduction: Would You Work Harder Because You're Controlled or Because You're Inspired?
Walk into a factory from the early twentieth century and you would find a workplace built on monitoring, rules and control. Walk into a modern digital business today and you are more likely to find collaboration areas, flexible working and continual development. This contrast points to one of the most important shifts in Human Resource Management (HRM): the move from Hard HRM to Soft HRM. Hard HRM treats employees as resources to be managed efficiently to improve performance. Inspired by the Michigan Model (Fombrun, Tichy and Devanna, 1984), it emphasises workforce planning, performance monitoring, tight management and cost reduction. While this can increase productivity, heavy reliance on control may sit uneasily with the engagement and creativity organisations want. In practice, Truss et al. (1997) show that the line between hard and soft approaches is often blurred. As economies became more knowledge-intensive, organisations found that controlling employees was not enough. This led ...